The Best Dog Flea Collars: Keep Your Canine Friend Safe & Healthy

If dogs had a pet of their own, it would undoubtedly be fleas and ticks. The only difference is that these are unwanted pests more than welcome friends!

Fleas and ticks might be common among dogs, but their dangers shouldn’t be downplayed. They are irritating pests at best. At their worst, however, they can pose serious health risks to you and your dog via viruses and infections.

Unfortunately, getting rid of them isn’t a trivial matter. There are lots of options out there, yes, but not all of them are safe for your dog.

How do you know which one to pick?

We were faced with that same dilemma! So, to help both ourselves and you, we decided to create one of the most comprehensive dog flea collar reviews on the web!

Our Top Pick

For the best dog flea collar, we choose the Bayer Seresto Flea and Tick Collar. It’s capable of both treatment and prevention, plus it’s safe for your dog to use.

 

The Top Flea Collars Reviewed

Bayer Seresto Flea and Tick Collar

The Bayer Seresto Flea and Tick Collar is a leading treatment and repelling collar that’s veterinarian approved.

 

Key Features

  • Imidacloprid and Flumenthrin that kills flea and ticks on contact
  • Slow-release over long periods
  • Non-greasy and odorless treatment that’s 100% safe for dogs
  • Works for eight months

 

What We Like

Bayer’s Seresto Collar is one of the most effective treatments collars we tried. Our Golden Retriever, which had a nasty flea infestation for months, was immediately cured within days of using this collar. Five months later, he is still flea free.

The slow-release action of the Seresto collar is just enough to kill off fleas, without wasting any dosage. This ensures it will last longer and continue to protect your pet. Despite being a treatment collar, the chemicals released by the collar is entirely odor-free and won’t irritate you or your dog.

 

What We Didn’t Like

Being a combination treatment and repelling collar, it is on the expensive side.

 

Pros

  • Its best advantage is that it works exceptionally well
  • The slow-release makes it last longer, making it more economical
  • Non-greasy and odorless, and it also won’t irritate the dog’s skin (at least from our experience)

 

Cons

  • A bit expensive
  • Hard to size for medium breeds

 

The Bayer Seresto is capable enough to be used in just about any level of flea treatment and prevention, making it the best dog flea collar, in our opinion.

 

Overall Rating – 4.9 / 5.0

CLICK HERE TO VIEW PRICE

Lucky Pluto Natural Dog Flea and Tick Collar

The Lucky Pluto Natural Dog Flea and Tick Collar is a repelling collar that uses only 100% natural ingredients.

 

Key Features

  • Uses only natural oils like Eucalyptus, Lavender, and Linaloe
  • Water-resistant collar— works in any weather, indoors or outdoors
  • Non-toxic and completely safe for your dog
  • Works for eight months

 

What We Like

If you’re a bit iffy on the chemicals and other unknown substances in a flea collar, consider the Lucky Pluto collar. Its main component is eucalyptus oil (66.6%), complemented by Lavender and Linaloe. All the above are derived from natural sources, so it’s wholly toxic-free and safe.

Another good thing is that this collar is waterproof. This means your dog can roll around wet grass or run under the rain, and the collar will still continue to protect him.

 

What We Didn’t Like

Though the majority of users are happy with this collar, we have read other dog owners having less than stellar results. Some claim it’s not effective at all in preventing fleas. Your situation may vary, though.

 

Pros

  • Uses only natural oils, so it’s completely safe for your dog to use
  • Easy sizing scheme makes fitting this collar to your dog very straightforward
  • Waterproof
  • Relatively affordable

 

Cons

  • In some instances, it might not be that effective

 

If you’re looking for a natural way to protect your dogs from fleas, the Lucky Pluto is the right choice.

 

Overall Rating – 4.5 / 5.0

CLICK HERE TO VIEW PRICE

Arava Flea and Tick Prevention Collar

The Arava Flea and Tick Prevention Collar is an all-natural repelling collar that’s safe enough to use with delicate puppies.

 

Key Features

  • Uses only 100% natural, safe, and non-toxic and botanical ingredients
  • Micro-injection technology releases oils in slow releases, making it last longer
  • MSDS tested and FDA certified
  • Works for six months

 

What We Like

Compared to other flea collars that also use natural ingredients, Arava’s flea collar uses a more potent formula. It contains a powerhouse of ingredients from lemongrass to citronella and even rosemary.

The great news is that it’s still all-natural and safe. In fact, it smells lovely, like what you would smell in aromatherapy candles. It also works as advertised. Our friend’s dog currently has zero fleas thanks to this collar, plus he says the dog also loves the smell—so win-win!

 

What We Didn’t Like

The natural ingredients in this collar might not be as potent or effective as an all-chemical prevention collar. For areas with low flea infestations, it’s a good trade-off.

 

Pros

  • Uses an all-natural formula that’s potent yet safe
  • The collar actually smells excellent, and there’s a big chance your dog will love it too
  • Waterproof, so you’re assured of 100% protection no matter the weather

 

Cons

  • Not as effective at repelling fleas as a chemical collar

 

The Arava Collar is the best dog flea collar if you’re looking for something natural and non-toxic. You just need to know its limitations and expect accordingly.

 

Overall Rating – 4.7 / 5.0

CLICK HERE TO VIEW PRICE

Only Natural Pet Easy Defense Dog Flea Tag

The Only Natural Pet Easy Defense is a premium, all-natural repelling collar that uses no chemicals whatsoever.

 

Key Features

  • Uses zero chemicals, pesticides or substances
  • Produces a natural frequency that naturally repels fleas
  • Comes as a tag, so it easily clips on to your dog’s existing collar
  • Works for up to 12 months

 

What We Like

The Only Natural Pet Easy Defense is unlike anything you’ll ever see in this whole article. That’s because it works in a completely unique way.

First, it uses no chemicals or substance whatsoever. Instead, it makes use of refined frequencies that, combined with your dog’s own energy, radiates a barrier that naturally repels fleas and ticks.

The upside to this is that this product introduces zero risk, irritations, or toxicity. It won’t ever harm your pet’s health.

Despite being skeptical at first, it actually works surprisingly well, in our experience. It might take a bit more time to work (three weeks according to the instructions), but it nevertheless does.

 

What We Didn’t Like

First, this works way slower than a chemical or even natural oil collar. It’s way more expensive than a repelling collar, too. Many people also don’t believe in this kind of “holistic treatment” and think of it as just some fake mumbo jumbo.

 

Pros

  • No chemicals at all make this 100% safe for any dog or pet
  • Last longer than any flea collar we tried
  • Easy to clip on to your dog’s collar, so no need to mess around with sizes

 

Cons

  • Takes longer to work
  • Expensive

 

The Only Natural Pet Easy Defense tag can be an effective and 100% safe flea prevention solution for your dog, despite it being a bit controversial.

 

Overall Rating – 4.5 / 5.0

CLICK HERE TO VIEW PRICE

Hartz Ultra Guard Reflective Flea and Tick Collar

The Hartz Ultra Guard Reflective Flea and Tick Collar is a comprehensive treatment collar that kills fleas at all stages of their life cycle.

 

Key Features

  • Reflect X-Shield kills all fleas, including their eggs and larvae
  • Reflective layer adds extra safety at night
  • Water-resistant material for use in any weather condition
  • Works for seven months

 

What We Like

The Hartz Ultra Guard, just as the name suggests, works exceptionally well at guarding your dog against fleas and ticks. However, it goes beyond protecting and actually kills them off.

This collar’s effectiveness lies in its X-Shield technology, which kills not just adult fleas, but prevents their eggs from hatching as well. Most other collars aren’t as effective as killing eggs and larvae, which doesn’t stem the infestation entirely.

The reflective strip also doubles as a night-safe collar, making it safer to walk your dog in low light conditions. It’s water-resistant, too.

 

What We Didn’t Like

The manufacturer claims it will work for seven months, but we found small signs of fleas coming back at the six-month mark. It might be best to replace it at that time.

 

Pros

  • Works to kill fleas at all levels, even the eggs, and larvae
  • Reflective strip and water resistance make it usable in any outdoor condition
  • Relatively inexpensive

 

Cons

  • Might not work as well past the 6-month mark

 

The Hartz UltraGuard is a collar that’s effective at completely eradicating fleas right down to the source.

 

Overall Rating – 4.4 / 5.0

CLICK HERE TO VIEW PRICE

Adams Flea and Tick Collar

The Adams Flea and Tick Collar is a treatment and repelling collar at a budget-friendly price.

 

Key Features

  • Active ingredients (Tetrachlorvinphos and (S)-Methoprene) kill fleas effectively on contact.
  • Waterproof, so it works even under wet conditions
  • Usable by pets with up to 26-inch neck width
  • Works for seven months

 

What We Like

The biggest draw of the Adams Flea and Tick Collar is the price. This is a very cheap collar at below $5, considering it’s aimed at both prevention and treatment of fleas.

Treatment wise, it’s quite useful, too. It killed most of the fleas and ticks of my friend’s dog for the first three days of use, with the rest being killed off in the next few days.

The waterproof design is also a big plus, as you don’t need to be extra careful with it when your pet runs around with it outdoors.

 

What We Didn’t Like

The odor is, unfortunately, highly detectable and unpleasant. The collar itself also feels fragile compared to other more durable collars, that are just a couple dollars pricier.

 

Pros

  • Amazing bargain price
  • Active ingredients work really well at killing off fleas and ticks
  • Generous sizing means it can easily fit any kind of breed

 

Cons

  • Unpleasant smell
  • Collar feels like it could easily break

 

Despite its flaws, the Adams Flea and Tick Collar is still a winner because it’s cheap, and it works.

 

Overall Rating – 4.1 / 5.0

CLICK HERE TO VIEW PRICE

PUMEK Dogs Flea and Tick Collar

The PUMEK Dogs Flea and Tick Collar is a comprehensive, all-natural repelling collar that’s approved by veterinarians.

 

Key Features

  • Made with only all-natural insect-repelling essential oils
  • Zero chemicals or pesticides
  • One size fits all, up to a neck width of 25 inches
  • Waterproof
  • Works for 12 months

 

What We Like

The PUMEK Dog Flea and Tick Collar works as well, like any other natural repelling dog collars out there. It uses only native plant oils to repel fleas and ticks effectively, so it’s entirely safe for your dog’s health.

But he great thing about this product is the number of rave dog flea collar reviews it has. Checking the verified purchasers on the web, you’ll only read about how the dog collar really works as advertised. This is an indication that this product is absolutely amazing.

It’s also completely waterproof, so your dog can bathe, swim, and run outdoors in the rain and still be protected by this collar.

 

What We Didn’t Like

Honestly, the only limitation this has is the fact that it’s a natural collar, meaning it’s not as effective as a chemical collar. Although one can argue that it’s much safer.

 

Pros

  • Works exceptionally well in repelling fleas
  • Uses only natural ingredients that are safe and non-toxic
  • Has only positive reviews on how it works
  • Waterproof
  • One size fits all

 

Cons

  • Not as effective as a chemical collar

 

The PUMEK Dog Flea and Tick Collar is a well-received, natural dog collar that’s quite effective.

 

Overall Rating – 4.8 / 5.0

CLICK HERE TO VIEW PRICE

Scalibor Protector Band

The Scalibor Protector Band is a veterinary-grade treatment collar that kills and protects from fleas and a wide variety of other dangerous pests.

 

Key Features

  • Capable of completely eradicating fleas and ticks
  • One size fits all design
  • Uses a patented release technology, so it works and lasts longer
  • Works for up to six months
  • Water-resistant
  • Uses safe and odorless chemicals with a good toxicity profile based on European sales

 

What We Like

The Scalibor Protector Band is an aggressive (but relatively safe) treatment collar that’s frequently recommended by veterinarians. In fact, we learned about this collar because our vet mentioned it.

Made by animal health company Intervet, Scalibor protects your dog from and kills a wide variety of pests, not just fleas. It’s also effective against sand flies, carriers of the Leishmania disease. Mosquitoes are also affected by this collar.

Even though it uses a chemical (deltamethrin), it’s virtually odorless and safe for dogs to use.

 

What We Didn’t Like

Since it’s pretty aggressive, it’s not suitable for all dog types. Specifically, it’s not to be used for puppies less than seven weeks old, or for those with open wounds.

 

Pros

  • 100% effective at killing off fleas, ticks, and even mosquitos
  • Veterinarian recommended, so you know it’s safe for dogs
  • Odorless release, so it’s not irritating to you or your dog

 

Cons

  • Not suitable for all dog types

 

If you want an effective treatment for a flea problem, the Scalibor Protector Band might just be what you need.

 

Overall Rating – 4.6 / 5.0

CLICK HERE TO VIEW PRICE

Healex Dog Flea Collar

The Healex Dog Flea Collar is a treatment and prevention collar that’s a veterinarian-approved alternative to Seresto.

 

Key Features

  • Recommended by over 250 veterinarians
  • Kills and repels fleas, lice, ticks, and mites, plus all their egg and larval stages
  • Uses a formula of 100% natural oils for 0% allergy rate
  • One size fits all
  • Works for eight months

 

What We Like

This Seresto alternative is actually for those who want the former’s effectiveness but without the potentially dangerous chemicals. Healex uses only natural essential oils, with citronella being the major one.

A few days into using it, so far, it’s working like a charm. We can actually see fleas moving away from the collar. The smell might be overpowering (not actually unpleasant), but that fades away after a few days—and not to worry, it will still continue to work.

 

What We Didn’t Like

While it poises itself as a Seresto alternative, unfortunately, it’s not as effective. We’re also doubtful of its ability to actually kill fleas. However, as a preventive measure, it works great.

 

Pros

  • Works great as a preventive measure to protect against fleas and other pests
  • Uses only natural ingredients, making it safer than Seresto
  • Relatively more affordable

 

Cons

  • Doesn’t work as well in killing fleas

 

The Healex Dog Flea Collar, in our opinion, is a preventive flea collar at best. Nevertheless, it’s still a useful and cheaper way to protect your dog if Seresto is over your budget.

 

Overall Rating – 4.2 / 5.0

CLICK HERE TO VIEW PRICE

Flea Collar Buying Guide

Why Fleas are Dangerous to your Dog’s Health

Fleas are one of the most common infestations your dog can catch. Despite their prevalence, however, they can be a source of a lot of health risks to your dog.

The flea is a tiny, wingless insect that relies on hopping through fur and hair. It’s a parasite that lives off the blood of larger mammals, notably dogs. They have evolved a flat body that enables them to weave through hair and fur with ease.

Their most dangerous feature, however, is their mouthparts, which can easily pierce the skin and drain the blood of its victims. If a flea moves from host to host, it has the potential of spreading infection and viruses. Nasty examples include tick paralysis, typhus, Lyme disease, and others.

Now, if your dog is infected and he accidentally bites you, what happens? Then you run the risk of getting infected, too! So, fleas, indirectly, also concern your health.

 

Even if fleas don’t bite your dog, it can still cause a host of other problems, including:

Irritation

The mere presence of fleas on your dog can irritate their skin. This will cause your dog to scratch excessively, or worse, attempt to remove them with their teeth. It will lead to their hair getting pull off or worse, breaking their skin. The wound itself will make your pet further prone to infection from other sources.

 

Anemia

Since fleas suck blood, your dogs might be at risk of anemia or severe blood loss. Now, this might not be a problem for bigger dogs (much like how a mosquito will unlikely drain enough blood from a human to cause anemia) but consider puppies or smaller dogs. Left untreated, anemia can cause them to contract further complications

 

Tapeworm Infection

This type of infection comes if your dog accidentally eats some of the fleas whenever he is trying to get rid of them. Sometimes, flea larvae feed on the eggs of the tapeworm, making them carriers once they reach adulthood.

Types of Flea Collars and How They Work

There are several flea collars available on the market, and they vary significantly in how they work. Most of these are dependent if you’re looking only to prevent a flea infestation or treat an already existing one.

Some flea collars are also capable of getting rid of a host of other pests, not just fleas. You can also consider these when choosing a flea collar, depending on your pet’s environment or situation

 

Preventive or Repelling Flea Collars

As with any infestation, prevention is definitely way better and easier than a cure. This is the principle that’s used with repelling flea collars, which is used way before a flea infestation exists or becomes a serious problem.

These flea collars work by releasing gas or other substance that fleas find repulsive. The idea is that fleas will try their hardest to avoid getting near your dog and therefore prevent an infestation.

In practice, however, this only works on a limited scale. Various flea collars have varying degrees of effectiveness, and some brands are better at it than others. A common problem is that the fleas will only avoid the area near the dog’s collar, but not the other parts of this body.

These flea collars are also pretty useless if there’s already an infestation going on, as it’s generally too weak to kill existing fleas.

The good news is that most repelling collars use natural or non-toxic gases that are safe for your dog. The most common one used is citronella, an oil sourced from a plant that’s often used in natural bug repellants.

You’ll usually know a repelling collar when words like “repel” or “prevent” are used when advertising it.

 

Treatment or Chemical Flea Collars

Stronger than the repellant collar, treatment flea collars are designed to eradicate all fleas on your dog, from adult to eggs. Because of this, treatment collars are also capable of working as a repellant since fleas will, of course, avoid getting killed by it.

They do this by placing medication or chemicals straight into your dog’s fur, killing any flea it comes into contact with. These chemicals are absorbed by the skin and spread throughout your dog’s body via the natural oils.

While they are effective at solving the problem, they achieve it by being aggressive. For some dogs, this can lead to several side effects. Some owners are also wary of using strong chemicals on their dogs. These flea collars should, therefore, be reserved only for the most severe of infestations.

You would know a treatment collar if the product description for it uses words like “kill” or “eradicate.”

 

Hybrid Collars

The best of both worlds, these types of flea collars combine the repelling and treating collars into one package. They are the most versatile and flexible, able to handle any flea-related problem.

The biggest drawback with these types of collars is the price, as they tend to be more expensive than either treatment or repelling collars alone.

 

How to Buy Flea Collars

There are many types of flea collars out there, and many will depend on your dog’s unique situation. Here are the key considerations you need to make:

 

How severe is their flea infestation?

This is probably the most critical factor to consider, as it will determine what type of flea collar you need to buy. If you’re just looking to protect your dog from fleas, find a repellant flea collar. If there’s a substantial infestation, grab a treatment collar.

However, for the most severe infestation, even the most robust flea collar might not be enough. If you can visibly see hundreds of fleas, then you might need to complement a collar with another solution, like anti-flea shampoo.

 

How long is it useful for?

Most flea collars are effective from anywhere from a month to around nine months. Of course, the longer the time, the more convenient and economical it is for you since you don’t need to replace it as often.

However, keep in mind that flea collars lose effectiveness the longer they are in use. If you notice an increasing number of fleas even before the flea collar’s suggested working period is over, consider replacing it prematurely.

 

Is it water-resistant?

The best flea collars should be water-resistant, including the chemicals that they use. Even if your dog is indoors most of the time, you never know when they will get wet or run around in the rain (dogs are unpredictable, after all). If you have a non-water-resistant collar, you run the risk of it not working, exposing your pet to fleas.

 

Final Thoughts

We’ve gone through quite a few options in one of the more comprehensive dog flea collar reviews on the web. The fact is that preventing or killing fleas in your dog is a very crucial process and choosing only the safest and most effective collar to do the job is vital.

But for the best dog flea collar that gets the job done, our money is on the Bayer Seresto Dog and Flea Collar. It’s an all-around product that both repels and kills off fleas and ticks. And despite it being a chemical collar, it’s still proven to be relatively safe for your dog.

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on email
Share on print
Share on whatsapp
Gail Ramirez

Gail Ramirez

Gail is an aspiring blogger, pet lover and Greys Anatomy, addict. Gail shares her experience on Pet Fashion Week as she studies to become a qualified vet.